By Brandon Witten, Owner, Family Tree Roofing, Bixby, OK
In short
- On an asphalt shingle roof, hail damage is a fresh impact that fractures or punctures the shingle. The marks are random, and they often come with dents in soft metal nearby.
- Normal wear is gradual and even: granules thinning across the whole roof, edges aging, or blisters that form as the shingle ages.
- Missing granules, by themselves, are not hail damage. Roofing engineers treat hail as functional damage when it fractures or punctures the shingle (NRCA, Professional Roofing).
Tulsa-area roofs get tested often. On May 21, 2024, National Weather Service storm reports logged hail up to 3 inches near Broken Arrow and up to 2 inches near Jenks and Bixby. That is why homeowners keep asking the same question after a storm: is this hail, or is it just an old roof?
Here is how we tell them apart, so you can read what you can see from the ground before anyone climbs a ladder.

What hail does to an asphalt shingle
A hailstone can do three things to a shingle:
- Fracture the mat. The fiberglass mat inside the shingle keeps water out. A hard hit can crack it from the underside while the top looks nearly fine. Inspectors often find these by feel, as a small soft spot that engineers call a “bruise” (NRCA).
- Knock granules loose in one spot. On a shingle in otherwise good condition, a fresh spot where the granules are suddenly gone and black asphalt shows usually means the mat underneath is fractured (NRCA).
- Leave a shallow dent with the granules still in place. Not every strike breaks the shingle. Hail often leaves very shallow indentations with gently sloped sides (InterNACHI).

Some places take more of a beating than others:
- Shingle edges and cutouts, because the neighboring shingle doesn’t support them (InterNACHI).
- Ridge caps, which the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) calls one of the most hail-vulnerable parts of a shingle roof (IBHS).
- Shingles that were cold when the hail hit. InterNACHI says temperatures below about 50°F leave shingles much more vulnerable.
What normal wear looks like
Wear and look-alikes share one trait: they follow the age and exposure of the roof, not the path of a storm.
- Granule loss over time. Shingles begin shedding granules when they are made, and gradual loss is normal weathering. When an old roof has lost granules evenly and shows exposed asphalt everywhere, with no fractures, it is usually near the end of its service life (NRCA). IBHS notes that granule loss along the edges is common and isn’t necessarily hail.
- Blistering. Blisters form when gas escapes from the asphalt. They leave steep-sided pits, often with asphalt missing, which is different from the shallow dents hail makes (InterNACHI).
- Curling and cupping. These are slow problems with several possible causes, including age, heat, poor attic ventilation and installation, and an engineering article on the subject does not tie them to hail (Roberts, Property Casualty 360).
- Marks from people and manufacturing. IBHS lists installation marks, mechanical marks (such as scuffs where someone walked or set a ladder) and manufacturing defects among the common look-alikes.
Side by side
| What you see | Hail | Normal wear | Blistering | Foot traffic or mechanical |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pattern | Random | Even across the roof | Widespread, similar-looking pits | In a line, or near equipment |
| Shape | Roundish spots; may feel soft | Thinning, aging edges | Steep-sided pits | Scuffs, creases, tears |
| Granules | Missing in a fresh spot, or still in a shallow dent | Thin overall | Missing inside the pit | Rubbed off along a path |
| The mat | May be fractured (felt from above, seen from below) | Not punctured | May be exposed in the pit | May be creased or torn |
| Around the house | Fresh dents in gutters, vents, A/C fins | None | None | None |
Clues you can check from the ground

You don’t need to be on the roof to find some of the best evidence.
- Soft metals keep a record. Look at gutters, downspouts, roof vents, window wraps and the thin aluminum fins on an A/C unit. Dents in metal are a lasting record of a hailstorm (NRCA).
- Spatter marks. Hail can knock grime, oxidation or algae off painted or dirty surfaces, leaving clean-looking spots. These typically fade within about a year (NRCA). IBHS points out that spatter isn’t damage by itself; it shows that hail came through.
Please stay off the roof. Wet or hail-roughened shingles are slippery, and you can damage a shingle you step on. Photograph what you can see from the ground.
How old is the damage?
It can be hard to date. Spatter marks help with recent storms because they fade within about a year, and NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information keep a public Storm Events Database of severe weather reports by county and date. It isn’t house-by-house, but it can show when hail was reported near you. Date-stamped photos taken soon after a storm make that match much easier.
Why the difference matters for an insurance claim
This is general information, not advice about your policy. Your policy’s wording controls, and we are roofers, not insurance agents or adjusters.
What policies cover. Homeowners policies generally cover sudden, accidental losses from causes such as wind and hail, and not gradual wear or maintenance (Maryland Insurance Administration describes the general rule; Oklahoma policies vary). That is why the hail-or-wear question comes up so often. If a claim is paid, how much you receive depends partly on how your policy treats depreciation.
Extra time for damage you couldn’t see. If your policy puts a time limit on wind or hail roof claims, Oklahoma law requires it to allow a claim after the first anniversary of the loss and up to 24 months after the date of loss when the damage was not evident without an inspection (36 O.S. § 1250.5(7); Oklahoma Insurance Department Bulletin 4-2022). The Department also encourages a roof inspection once a year and after a major hail or wind event.
What a roofer may and may not do. The Oklahoma Insurance Department’s notice to roofing contractors says a roofer may give an opinion on whether roof damage came from a storm, recommend that you file a claim, provide a repair estimate you can submit, and attend the adjuster’s inspection to answer the adjuster’s questions. A roofer may not negotiate your claim or act as your adjuster without a public adjuster license.
We stay on the contractor side of that line. We inspect, photograph and document what we find, write an estimate, and give you the documentation package. You decide whether to file, and you file and manage your own claim. We don’t negotiate with your insurer, interpret your policy or tell you what a claim will pay. More on that is on our roof insurance claim help page.
About deductibles. Oklahoma law bars a roofing contractor doing work paid from insurance proceeds from advertising or promising to pay any part of your deductible (59 O.S. § 1151.30; Oklahoma Insurance Department, May 2026). If a roofer offers, treat it as a warning sign.
What to do after a hailstorm
The Oklahoma Insurance Department’s storm guidance boils down to a few habits. Our storm damage page has the longer checklist; the short version:
- Write down the date of the storm.
- Take photos and video from the ground: roof slopes you can see, gutters, vents, A/C fins, window wraps.
- Stop active leaks with a temporary fix, such as a tarp, and keep every receipt.
- Hold off on permanent repairs until your insurance company has inspected.
- Get a roof inspection and more than one bid, and confirm any roofer’s registration with the Oklahoma Construction Industries Board.
What a hail inspection with us includes

A free inspection with Family Tree Roofing covers:
- every slope of the roof, plus the gutters, vents and other soft metals
- the attic, when it’s accessible, to look for leaks and ventilation problems
- photos of what we find, with hail and ordinary age noted separately
- a plain-language explanation of what we found
- a written estimate of the work the roof needs
- a documentation package of photos and the estimate, which you can give your insurer if you decide to file
If a shingle analysis shows a wind- or hail-damaged roof can be repaired properly, we recommend the repair. If the damage is age, we tell you that too. If you want us there when the adjuster inspects, we can attend to answer the adjuster’s questions.
Book a free roof inspection or call 918-703-3735. We serve Tulsa, Bixby, Broken Arrow, Jenks, Owasso, Sapulpa, Glenpool, Sand Springs, Coweta and Claremore. Residential roofing only.
Questions people ask
Are granules in my gutters a sign of hail?
Not by themselves. Every asphalt roof sheds granules as it weathers. What points to hail is a fresh dark spot where granules are missing on a shingle that is otherwise in good shape, or dents in soft metal nearby.
I can’t see anything from the ground. Could there still be hail damage?
Yes. A fracture can sit on the underside of the shingle and show up only as a soft spot you feel. That is why the Oklahoma Insurance Department encourages an inspection after a major hail event, not just when something looks wrong.
Can hail damage be repaired, or does the whole roof need replacing?
It depends on how many shingles are fractured, whether matching shingles are still made, and whether the surrounding shingles are in shape to be worked on. Read our roof repair page for more.
Sources are linked in the text. Information checked against the sources named, November 2026.